Which Accounts Should You Withdraw From First in Retirement? IRA, Roth, or Savings?
Retirement income planning • By Flavio Medeiros
The short answer
There is no single best order for retirement withdrawals. Spending taxable savings first, traditional IRA or 401(k) money next, and Roth funds last can be a starting point. But a coordinated mix may better fit your taxes, required distributions, Medicare premiums, and spending needs. Build the withdrawal plan around your household, then revisit it each year.
You spent decades deciding how much to save. Retirement brings a different question: Which account should pay the bills?
A savings account, brokerage account, traditional IRA, and Roth IRA may all help fund retirement, but taking the same dollar amount from each can have different consequences. A useful plan connects the money you need today with the decisions you may face five or ten years from now.
First, understand what you are withdrawing
The account label matters, but so does what is inside it. A “cash bucket” held in a traditional IRA has different tax treatment from cash held in a regular bank account.
| Account | Federal tax considerations | Planning question |
|---|---|---|
| Bank savings and cash | Moving existing principal generally does not create income; interest can be taxable. | How much reserve should remain available? |
| Taxable brokerage account | Selling investments can realize gains or losses; the entire sale amount is not necessarily taxable. | Which holdings and tax lots make sense to sell? |
| Traditional IRA or pretax 401(k) | Pretax distributions generally create ordinary income; after-tax basis can change the calculation. | How much income should be recognized this year? |
| Roth IRA | Qualified withdrawals are federally tax-free. Other withdrawals require attention to ordering and five-year rules. | Would using Roth money now help with a specific expense or income limit? |
General overview only. State taxes, account history, age, and plan rules can change the result. See IRS Publication 550, Topic 409, and Publication 590-B.
Should you spend savings or IRA money first?
Start with the spending gap, then compare the account choices. Add up expected expenses and subtract income such as Social Security or a pension. The remaining gap tells you what your accounts need to provide, before allowing for any taxes on withdrawals.
Using taxable savings first can preserve retirement accounts. Yet postponing every pretax withdrawal may leave fewer choices later. If a large IRA is likely to produce substantial future distributions, recognizing some income earlier may deserve consideration. The right comparison is a multiyear projection, rather than this year's tax bill alone.
Here are four reasons to adjust a simple “savings, then IRA, then Roth” rule.
1. Required minimum distributions can set part of the schedule
Once required minimum distributions apply, you must address them whether or not you need all that cash for spending. Under current law, the starting age is generally 73 for people born in 1951–1959 and 75 for those born in 1960 or later. Older birth years follow earlier rules. Employer-plan and inherited-account rules need separate attention.
An RMD does not have to be spent, but it cannot be rolled over or converted to a Roth IRA. Your own Roth IRA has no lifetime RMD requirement. Learn more in our guide to planning for RMD taxes and the IRS RMD FAQs.
2. Lower-income years may create planning choices
The period after work ends and before other income begins may be worth reviewing. You could compare a planned pretax withdrawal with a partial Roth conversion, rather than assuming the IRA should remain untouched.
A conversion moves money to a Roth account; it does not provide spending cash. Its taxable portion adds income in the conversion year. Compare today's tax cost with the possible future benefit, and identify how the tax will be paid. Our Roth conversion overview explains the broader decision. The IRS conversion rules also apply.
3. Medicare and Social Security belong in the calculation
Extra income can affect more than your tax bracket. Medicare's income-related monthly adjustment amount, or IRMAA, can raise Part B and Part D costs. Social Security generally uses tax information from two years earlier, so a taxable withdrawal or conversion may affect a later premium year. Qualified Roth withdrawals generally do not add to that income.
Other income can also make a larger portion of Social Security benefits taxable. Up to 85% of benefits may be included in taxable income; that does not mean an 85% tax rate. Compare these effects together, rather than treating each account in isolation. See our Medicare IRMAA guide, SSA's premium guidance, and SSA's benefit-tax explanation.
4. A large expense can change this year's mix
A roof replacement, vehicle purchase, or family expense may require a different combination from your usual monthly income. Consider which assets are available, their tax consequences, and the reserve you want afterward. A Roth withdrawal can be useful here, even if preserving Roth funds remains a longer-term goal.
A hypothetical example: one income gap, several choices
Meet a fictional retired couple
They are both 66, expect $78,000 in annual spending, and receive $42,000 from Social Security and a pension. Their accounts total $1 million:
- $100,000 in bank savings
- $200,000 in a taxable brokerage account
- $600,000 in traditional IRAs
- $100,000 in Roth IRAs
Their starting spending gap is $36,000 a year, or $3,000 a month , before adjusting for taxes.
They could fund it from savings. They could use an IRA distribution. Or they could combine cash, investment sales, and IRA withdrawals. Their advisor would compare the alternatives using tax basis, expected income, future RMDs, reserves, and Medicare costs.
Illustration only; not an actual client, recommended allocation, tax calculation, or projection. The $36,000 gap excludes additional withdrawal taxes. No strategy is assumed to produce a specific saving or investment return.
The useful question is not simply which account comes first. It is which combination supports this household's spending and longer-term plan.
How does the Three-Bucket Strategy fit?
A bucket strategy organizes assets around when you expect to use them. Withdrawal sequencing addresses which accounts supply that money and what happens when they do. These are connected decisions.
- Near-term spending: Identify accessible funds for upcoming expenses and a reasonable reserve.
- Intermediate needs: Plan how later spending and reserve replenishment could be funded.
- Longer-term growth: Consider assets intended for needs further into retirement, consistent with your risk tolerance.
Then consider the tax wrapper around each holding. A bucket label does not make an IRA distribution tax-free, and setting aside cash does not eliminate inflation or investment risk. Your plan also needs a practical process for refilling reserves and reviewing withdrawals.
Five questions to review before choosing an account
- What is our spending gap after other income?
- Do we have an RMD or another distribution deadline?
- What income, gains, and taxes would each option create?
- Could the decision affect Medicare costs or Social Security taxation?
- What reserves and future account balances would remain?
Review the answers annually and before a major withdrawal. If you retire before 59½, review access rules first: some retirement distributions can trigger additional taxes unless an exception applies. An inherited account also needs its own analysis.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best order to withdraw retirement money?
There is no universal order. First identify required distributions and your spending gap, then compare taxable, pretax, and Roth sources using a household income projection.
Should I always spend my taxable account first?
No. That approach can be a starting point, but it may overlook opportunities to recognize pretax income earlier or manage future withdrawals. Investment gains and losses also matter.
Should a Roth IRA always be the last account I use?
No. Preserving it can support future flexibility, while using qualified Roth withdrawals for a particular expense may help manage current taxable income. The choice depends on your goals and account rules.
Can retirement withdrawals increase Medicare premiums?
Yes, if they increase the income used for IRMAA enough to cross an applicable threshold. Not every withdrawal is taxable, and Medicare generally looks back two tax years.
Is withdrawal order the same as the 4% rule?
No. Withdrawal order concerns which accounts supply income. A withdrawal-rate guideline concerns how much you take from a portfolio. Neither replaces a spending and investment plan tailored to your situation.
Reviewed October 18, 2026. This article provides general education, not individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. Rules and personal circumstances can change. Coordinate decisions with your financial advisor and tax professional. Investment strategies involve risk and do not guarantee results.
Ready to Review Your Retirement Plan?
Our fiduciary advisors work with pre-retirees and retirees nationwide. No cost, no obligation — just a real conversation about your future.
Recent Posts
